BA case won’t stop recruiting
Doesn’t it make you feel good to know our tax dollars are always hard at work, especially in the judicial system?
I feel a lot better about this country, and quite frankly I’ve slept better over the past couple of days knowing our Supreme Court is hard at work deliberating on such monumental things as high school football recruiting.
In case you missed it, our Supreme Court ruled last week in favor of the Tennessee Secondary School Athletic Association in a decision that upholds limits on high school sports recruiting.
The dispute came about when Brentwood Academy coach Carlton Flatt sent out a dozen letters to eighth-graders in 1997 inviting then to attend spring training at the school.
Now the TSSAA governs high school sports here in Tennessee, and in its bylaws bars schools from contacting prospective students about their sports programs. Remember this key word ‘prospective.’
The students who are at the center of this ridiculous argument had already been accepted and signed a enrollment contract to begin school in the fall of 1997 at Brentwood Academy. Brentwood is a private school and enrollment is limited so parents have to sign their kids up early to get them in the school.
In the letter Flatt told the boys that equipment would be distributed and getting involved as soon as possible would be to their advantage.
Now, I’m against recruiting in high school sports, but it has gone on for years. But this in my opinion does not fall under a recruiting law set forth by the TSSAA.
First of all remember that key word ‘prospective.’ These kids were already registered to attend Brentwood. They weren’t looking to go some place else. Prospective students would mean they still had options of attending another school, these kids didn’t fall under that category.
Justice John Paul Stevens wrote, ‘hard-sell tactics directed at middle school students could lead to exploitation, distort competition between high school teams and foster an environment in which athletics are prized more highly than academics.’
Folks, for some schools here in the middle Tennessee area academics have taken a back seat to athletics for many, many years. That’s not the way it should be, but it’s a fact.
If the TSSAA is going to take a stand on recruiting then what about all those coaches who for years have looked outside of their own town, and sometimes state, for blue-chip football players?
It’s a fairly common practice for some of the more elite coaches to find these young superstars and bring them to their schools by offering to find their parents good-paying jobs. That’s all it takes for some folks to up and move from one town to the next.
Let’s say I’m coaching in Murfreesboro and somewhere in Alabama I hear about this seventh-grader who is going to be the next Herschel Walker. The family is going through some hard times and jobs are scarce in their small southern town.
A few connections with Nissan and a couple of phone calls later the next Herschel Walker and his family are moving to Murfreesboro. Now that’s recruiting.
The Brentwood case should have never made it to the Supreme Court, but something like this doesn’t surprise me when it comes to the higher powers of the TSSAA.
