Hate crimes get narrow definition
Hate Crime: ‘Any act of intimidation, harassment, physical force or threat of physical force directed against any person ‘ or their property or advocate, motivated either in whole or in part by hostility to their real or perceived race, ethnic background, religious belief, sex, age, disability, or sexual orientation, with the intention of causing fear or intimidation, or to deter the free exercise or enjoyment of any rights or privileges secured by the Constitution or the laws of the United State of California whether or not performed under color of law’ (Final Report of the Attorney General’s Commission on Racial, Ethnic, Religious and Minority Violence, issued April, 1986).
Over the past few years, many old civil right, hate crime murder cases have been reopened and retried. For example: Emmett Till (1955, Mississippi); Medger Evers (Mississippi, 1963); 16th Street Church bombing, where four young black girls were senselessly murdered (Alabama, 1963); and other similar cases.
Concerning these ‘hate crimes’ and the reopening of them, some convictions were won, and the alleged perpetrators received stiff prison sentences. For the most part, I feel justice was served. However, on the downside, I, and others, have some problems with how our justice system handles hate crimes.
First, there is an issue concerning the accuracy of a witness testifying about what he/she saw and heard 50-plus years ago. If one has read and watched media coverage of these hate crime cases, it could be surmised that the testimonies of key witnesses were rehearsed, choreographed, and, worse yet, possibly coerced.
Second, concerning the reopening of these civil rights-related murders, there exists a disturbing pattern: All the victims were black; all the perpetrators were white. And all the crimes took place in the Deep South.
Now, I ask, can you name one single incident where a black, or some other minority, murdered a white, and it was labeled, and tried, as a hate crime? If the answer is ‘no,’ are we, as a society, saying that every time a white kills a black, or some other minority, it, indeed, is a hate crime?
And when a black/minority murders a white it never is a hate crime, but, instead, only an act of violence? If the answer is ‘yes,’ is this not the quintessential definition of politically correct cowardice, and forget about the balanced rendering of justice?
On Jan. 6-7, 2007, in Knoxville, Tennessee, Hugh Christopher Newsom, Jr., 23, and Channon Gail Christian, 21, a white couple out on a date, were abducted by four black males, and both were brutally raped and murdered. (NOTE: A black female supposedly was involved.)
Yet more worrisome, there is strong speculation that, due to the racial implications and possibilities, an effort initially was put forth by certain media outlets to keep this rape/murder case hushed up. In his June 7, 2007 column, Tennessean writer Dwight Lewis ‘ predictable as next month’s electric bill ‘ quoted Mark Potok, editor of The Intelligence Report , as saying: ‘These were incredible savage killings, but they were not motivated by race.’ How does Potok or Lewis know absolutely, for sure? Neither witnessed the murders, did he? How lame and insulting does it get!
One thing, for certain, can be said about ‘hate crimes.’ They are indiscriminate because no race is immune either as victim or perpetrator.
Mike Vinson is a Warren County columnist. He can be reached at [email protected].
