Skip to content

Winkler to request new trial Friday

SELMER, Tenn. (AP) ‘ A minister’s wife convicted of killing her husband will ask for a new trial Friday when she returns to court for sentencing, a defense lawyer said Tuesday.

Mary Winkler faces up to six years in prison on a voluntary manslaughter conviction for shooting her husband, Matthew Winkler, in the back with a shotgun in March 2006.

Winkler, 33, went to trial in April on a first-degree murder charge, but her jury returned a verdict for manslaughter, a much less serious crime, following testimony she had been physically and mentally abused by her husband.

If granted a new trial, Winkler could not be recharged with murder, since the jury acquitted her of that charge when it found her guilty of the lesser offense, said defense lawyer Steve Farese.

‘It’s a double-jeopardy type of argument,’ said Farese, who will argue Winkler’s motion at sentencing in McNairy County Circuit Court.

Motions for new trials are common in criminal convictions. Winkler’s petition was filed Friday with Judge Weber McCraw, who presided over her trial and will decide on her sentence.

Winkler will be eligible for parole after serving about a third of any prison time, and it is possible she could get a suspended sentence and probation. She will also get credit for five months spent in jail before trial.

Winkler argues that McCraw wrongly rejected several defense motions on courtroom evidence during the trial, including attempts to exclude items seized from her home and testimony on her personal finances.

Matthew Winkler, the pulpit minister at Fourth Street Church of Christ in Selmer, was killed at the church parsonage where he and his wife lived with their three young daughters.

Mary Winkler is also in a legal fight with her husband’s parents, Dan and Diane Winkler, over custody of those daughters, now ages 9, 7 and 2.

Leave a Comment