Skip to content

Kilcullen comments skewed

‘If I were a Muslim, I’d probably be a jihadist. The thing that drives these guys ‘ a sense of adventure, wanting to be part of the moment, wanting to be in the big movement of history that’s happening now ‘ that’s the same thing that drives me, you know’?

No. I don’t know. And I sorely wish I could tell him so ‘ ‘him’ being David Kilcullen, senior counterinsurgency adviser to Gen. David Petraeus, senior U.S. commander in Iraq.

With this bizarro depiction of jihadists-as-swashbucklers, Lt. Col. David Kilcullen, an Australian Army officer ‘on loan’ to the U.S. government, should probably have been sent back with: ‘And I suppose if you had been a German during a certain world war, you would have been a Nazi, eh? Who more than those Third Reich ‘guys’ wanted to be in ‘the big movement of history’? Grr. Thanks, mate, but no thanks. Go play Abu Robin al-Hood down under.’

Such remarks convey either noncomprehension or indifference to the evil nature of jihad. Or both. Such neutrality, if that’s the word for it, also marks Kilcullen’s discussion of his big, formative idea: lessons drawn from what he refers to as ‘an Islamic insurgency in West Java and a Christian-separatist insurgency in East Timor.’

In the latter case, the language is jarring for what Serge Trifkovic has described this way: ‘In the motivation, patterns and perceptions of the actors on the ground ‘ killers and victims alike ‘ East Timor was an Islamic jihad against Christian infidels’ that left as many as 200,000 East Timorese dead.

IIt’s hard to say what’s worse: ignorance of jihad, for which there’s no excuse at this advanced stage of war, or indifference to it, for which there’s never an excuse. Both attitudes deeply imbue U.S. war policy. As Kilcullen would (and has) put it, ‘the Islamic bit is secondary.’

The New Yorker story continues: Although ‘radical ideas’ lead young men to become jihadists, ‘the reasons they convert, Kilcullen said, are more mundane and familiar: family, friends, associates.’

Sounds like our problem is a cell calling plan, not jihadist Islam. Little wonder Kilcullen is also down on the phrase ‘war on terror.’ That’s because, as Packer writes, the concept (elliptical as it is) ‘suggests an undifferentiated enemy’ engaged in global jihad. David Kilcullen strives to ‘disaggregate’ insurgencies by disconnecting the Islamic dots linking various terror-states and terrorists. He prefers to see jihadist movements in terms of so many local grievances. It’s as if he has taken the defunct Bush doctrine ‘ You’re with us or you’re against us ‘ and changed it to: You’re really not with anyone, and certainly not anyone Islamic.

To what end? Difficult to say, particularly when, according to the New Yorker, his example of ‘disaggregation’ is the Indonesian province of Aceh. Here, he maintains, Western tsunami aid and resentment of outsiders prevented Aceh from ‘becoming,’ as the article put it, ‘part of the global jihad’ ‘ a funny sort of victory to claim in a place where, increasingly, sharia rules.

Diana West is a columnist for The Washington Times. She can be contacted via [email protected].

Leave a Comment