Lawyers to talk to jurors about $4.2M award
With jurors awarding family members of a man who died after his stay at NHC McMinnville millions of dollars, lawyers in the case have won permission to interview the jurors to find out what led to the record civil judgment.
In an order handed down by Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley in the case of the Estate of Chethum Myers versus NHC and its subordinate companies, the court said it would allow attorneys on both sides to interview jurors who decided the case.
?The court finds that the parties may be allowed to talk with the jurors,? Stanley said in his ruling. ?The parties must abide by the rules of ethics (in doing the interviews).?
The ruling comes as appeals prepare to be filed by both the plaintiff and defense after the $4.2 million compensatory award against NHC and its three subordinate companies, which includes NHC McMinnville.
The award was given by a jury last month after it found NHC was at least partially to blame for substandard treatment of the 89-year-old prior to his death.
It is the appeals which prompt the interviews of jurors, interviews which will only be allowed to a certain extent.
?When questioning a juror, if information comes to light which could overturn or alter the verdict, the attorney is to stop questioning the juror immediately and notify this court,? Stanley directed, noting the juror would then be brought to court and questioned with all parties present.
Specifically, the plaintiffs said NHC placed profits over people in short staffing its care facilities to maximize profits. It was during that time the plaintiffs said Myers was allowed to take seven falls, at one point fracturing his hip and waiting a week before it was treated. The plaintiffs also claimed the victim suffered bad bed sores and that a catheter had led to an infection which may have later led to his death.
While the defense maintained it staffed the facility beyond state requirements, jurors in the case not only found NHC negligent, awarding compensatory damages, but also tried to award the plaintiffs what would be a record punitive damage in the amount of $29.6 million.
However, the trial court set aside most of the punitive damages with the exception of $163,402 against NHC McMinnville saying there was no evidence of reckless behavior on the part of the national company. The setting aside of punitive judgment and the finding of compensatory damages against the defendants is what has led to plans for both sides to appeal.
