Skip to content

Unreasonable search and seizure

Here’s an artifact of archaic, pre-9/11 thinking I found on the Internet: “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”

Readers who remained alert through high school may recognize the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Awfully stuffy, don’t you think? Who says “shall” anymore? “Particularly describing,” indeed. No red-blooded patriot would use the phrase. It reads like something written by sissies in powdered wigs. Besides, who’s to say what’s unreasonable if not our Glorious Leader, George W. Bush?

In Bushworld, if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear. In Bushworld, we don’t need no stinkin’ warrants. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales emphatically assured Congress in November 2005 that a Washington Post article suggesting widespread misuse of so-called “national security letters” (NSL) by the FBI was substantially false. A veritable parade of administration witnesses assured congressmen contemplating the re-enactment of the Patriot Act that stringent Justice Department supervision prevented it.

NSLs are a potential police-state tool, essentially granting investigators sweeping powers previously enjoyed by such innovators in security as the Soviet KGB. Issued entirely without judicial oversight — no prosecutors, judges or grand juries — they allow the Feds a secret peek at intimate aspects of our lives.

NSL recipients like banks and telephone companies are forbidden to notify customers that their records have been copied into FBI databases. Combined with widespread wiretapping conducted by the National Security Administration in clear defiance of the 1978 FISA law requiring warrants from a secret court, they render privacy rights all but nonexistent.

And here’s the beauty part: It’s all Top Secret. Nobody can contest these abuses in court because nobody can prove they have legal “standing.” It’s not just Orwell’s “1984” that needs frequent rereading, but Heller’s “Catch-22.”

So now we learn, courtesy of a report by the Justice Department’s Inspector General, that the Post’s 2005 series greatly understated the FBI’s systematic abuse of NSLs. Exactly as those periwigged Founding Fathers, having had their fill of arbitrary seizures and arrests under King George III, would have predicted. Unregulated executive powers not limited by courts or legislatures WILL be misused.

Every.

Single.

Time.

It seems the FBI’s been handing out NSLs like popcorn, at least 47,000 through 2005, often in cases bearing no relationship to national security whatsoever, and substantially without meaningful supervision.

Last January, Gonzales casually suggested during a Senate hearing that the right of habeas corpus, guaranteeing a fair trial to every American, might not exist. “The Constitution doesn’t say every individual in the United States or citizen is hereby granted or assured the right of habeas corpus,” he observed placidly. “It doesn’t say that. It simply says the right shall not be suspended” except in cases of rebellion or invasion.

How long before Gonzales reminds us that the word “privacy” doesn’t appear there, either?

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette columnist Gene Lyons can be reached at [email protected].

Leave a Comment