Taking A Stand – Ducker?s sentence was way too long
After serving more than 11 years behind bars, Jennie Bain Ducker, 32, is set to be freed from prison on parole, one year before she would have flattened out her sentence for the June 6, 1995 hyperthermia deaths of her children, Devin and Dustin Ducker.
While I?ve always been a law and order, hang ?em high kind of guy when it comes to punishment of law breakers, the whole idea of sentencing this mother to 18 years in prison for what was proven during trial to be an accident brought on by a plain lack of good judgment and responsibility was a waste of her life and our resources. Yes, she deserved to serve time for their deaths, but convicting her on aggravated child abuse, a crime which carries 15 to 25 years, was a bit much.
I had three jurors come forward after the trial to say they felt pressured by other jurors to find the then 20-year-old woman guilty on the Class B felony charge when they wanted to give her a lesser sentence.
I agree with those three jurors. Not only did I sit through every single minute of testimony, but I also attended all pre-trial and post-trial motion hearings and found nothing that would have warranted a conviction on the charge of aggravated child abuse.
I have no doubt Ms. Ducker was legitimately sorrowful for the loss of her children and I also have no doubt it was an accident. Unlike rumors which circulated around the community that there was a wild party at the motel that night, there was never any evidence to suggest any kind of wild party.
Actually, it was quite the opposite. Evidence and other witnesses I spoke to revealed she had just come there to hang out and wasn?t meaning to stay long, explaining why the kids were left in her car. And, had this been such a wild party, my question is why she would have fallen asleep if you keep in mind alcohol tests did not suggest she was drunk.
What I think happened was a retribution verdict. We had two dead children who passed away in a horrible death inside their mother?s car which hit temperatures of 120 degrees on that 90-degree day. Then, we had jurors, all likely with children themselves, who felt someone had to stand up for the children.
Add this to allegations of alcohol use, her being out that time of night and her stoned look during the court proceedings (she was on psychological drugs from what I understand) and her fate was sealed, even though if you read the aggravated child abuse code there?s no way that verdict should have been reached.
Under the letter of the law it should have either been first-degree murder by child abuse (the Scotty Trexler Law) or something lesser like reckless homicide. Of course the law rarely stops juries around here from doing what they want, the outcome of which is sometimes good and sometimes bad according to who you ask.
The bottom line is we had a woman in jail for over 11 years for nothing other than retribution while we have a revolving door for dangerous offenders who get out only to commit another crime before supper that night.
Had I thought she was partying that night and cared less about her children, I wouldn?t be writing this column right now. But, based on the evidence and not some Old Testament license to stone the sinner, I believe it was an accident and that we as a society likely tried to take two wrongs and make a right out of it. In this case, everybody lost.
Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
