Skip to content

Former Smithville broker pleads guilty to fraud

A former Smithville insurance broker accused of scamming more than 50 people in an investment scheme pleaded guilty Friday to 15 counts of federal wire fraud.

B. Don James, a once-trusted and respected small-town businessman, could face 10 years in federal prison when U.S. District Judge Todd Campbell sentences him in May.

James was indicted by a Nashville federal grand jury Dec. 21 and was facing a trial set to begin this month. The U.S. attorney?s office accused James of failing to invest $1.8 million of investors? money as promised between 1997 and 2004. Investors say he made off with millions more.

James was, by all accounts, a respected DeKalb County businessman until his investment scheme imploded in 2004.

Around 1993, James formed a company and dubbed it Investors Insurance Finance LLC. The company aimed to get around commercial insurance practices at the time. The practice then was to require business owners to pay their full premiums in full upfront.

However, Investors Insurance would allow businesses needing insurance to make installment payments. The company would make the full upfront premium, and then collect a monthly payment, plus an additional fee, from the businesses.

To cover the premium costs, James’ company recruited investors, who were told they would receive a 10 percent annual return. But James did not use the funds in that way.

The program imploded when a key investor associated with James, Smithville lawyer and banker M. Douglas Hodges, stopped investing money in 2004, U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee John McLemore has said. McLemore has overseen James? assets and records since investors forced James into bankruptcy in 2005.

Without new money from Hodges, James could not pay his other investors, McLemore said.

Last year, Hodges won an $11.9 million judgment against James.

A Cookeville civil court jury also awarded $8 million to 68 people ? mostly Smithville residents ? who had sued Hodges for allegedly helping James.

Back in Smithville, James? guilty pleas did not come as a shock to at least one of his victims, nor did it provide any real sense of relief.

Heskel Hawkins said he had invested his $2 million inheritance with James ? and lost it all.

?That man caused me a whole world of trouble,? Hawkins said.

?See most of us, we grew up with him, knew him from childhood,? said Nell Beshearse, another investor. ?So, that man, all he had to do was talk to us. He had him a little spiel for everybody. ?You know me, I won?t run off with your money,? and ?The only way you could lose your money is if I run off.? That?s how he got us.?

Beshearse invested $30,000 with James.

Leave a Comment