Skip to content

Winkler files motion to suppress evidence – Says police illegally searched family home

SELMER, Tenn. ? Lawyers for a minister?s wife argued in court Thursday that police illegally searched her family home after her husband was found shot to death on a bedroom floor.

Mary Winkler, 32, is charged with first-degree murder in the slaying, and defense lawyers want potential evidence seized at the Church of Christ parsonage excluded from her trial.

The defense also wants to exclude potential evidence, including bank records, police were led to because of the residential search.

Prosecutors refuse to give a motive for the shooting, but Winkler told authorities she shot her 31-year-old husband, Matthew, after a night of arguing over finances and other family matters.

Her lawyers say the family had fallen victim to a foreign check scam. They also imply their client was physically and emotionally abused by her husband.

Defense lawyer Steve Farese said Matthew Winkler had been pronounced dead by a physician and no one else was in danger when police searched the home on March 22.

?Once that place was secure, they had to get a search warrant,? Farese said at a hearing before Judge Weber McCraw.

Mary Winkler was taken into custody the day after the slaying in Orange Beach, Ala., where she fled with the couple?s three young daughters.

Winkler, Farese and co-counsel Leslie Ballin refused comment as they arrived and left for the hearing at the Selmer courthouse, about 80 miles east of Memphis.

Prosecutor Walter Freeland said local police and agents with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation conducted themselves properly at the Winkler home. The family?s finances would have been investigated, he said, no matter what was turned up by the search.

?Just by going to the local bank, you could do it,? Freeland said.

Prosecutors did not say what items taken from the home might be used at trial. The shotgun believed to be used in the slaying was seized at the time of Mary Winkler?s arrest.

Weber said he would issue a written ruling on the defense request. He did not say when.

Winkler is free on bond and living in Warren County until her trial. No date has been set.

Matthew Winkler?s body was found by members of the Fourth Street Church of Christ after the pastor and his family failed to show up for an evening service.

William Eason, a physician and church elder, was one of the four congregation members who went to the parsonage.

?Matthew was obviously dead,? Eason said. ?He was lying on his back beside the bed.?

Chris Carpenter, a TBI investigator, said items seized from the home included a copy of a $6,400 check from an undisclosed source in Canada made out to Mary Winkler. Among other items, investigators also seized a folder of financial records and a box of blank checks, Carpenter said.

Leave a Comment