Alderman nearly thrown from meeting – Confrontation gets heated between Davenport, Wood
Tempers flared Tuesday night between Mayor Royce Davenport and Alderman Billy Wood ? with the confrontation escalating to the point where Davenport threatened to have Wood removed from the room.
The argument erupted in a regular meeting of the Board of Mayor and Aldermen when Wood pushed to immediately hire local resident Hank Patton as the city?s next urban forester.
Davenport maintained the Building and Grounds Committee must first recommend a candidate to the full board before action is taken.
?You are trying to appease a couple of people,? Wood told Davenport, claiming the mayor was personally trying to block Patton from getting the job. ?It is my opinion that my committee will not be able to agree on an urban forester and I am asking this board to make the decision. I don?t believe you have the authority to stop me.?
It was that remark that provoked Davenport?s anger. Davenport threatened to rule Wood out of order and remove him from the room if he didn?t settle down.
The heated verbal exchange left Alderman Jimmy Haley wondering about the city board?s ability to act decisively. McMinnville has been without a city administrator for over a year and been without an urban forester since last May.
?It has gotten to the point that this board has become a division maker and not a decision maker,? said Haley.
Tuesday?s argument began when Wood attempted to bypass the committee system and have the full board hire Patton as urban forester.
?I would like to make a motion to authorize the city to immediately take all steps necessary to appoint Hank Patton as urban forester at the advertised salary and give him nine months to obtain his arborist certification,? said Wood.
The request received a quick response from Mayor Davenport who immediately stopped the motion in its tracks.
?I move that motion out of order,? said Davenport. ?Our current ordinance states that the city administrator has the authority to hire for that position.?
After Wood pointed out McMinnville currently doesn?t have a city administrator, Davenport said he has been acting as city administrator for the last year by the authority of the board.
?Is that by the board?s authority or your own authority?? asked Wood. ?Can I see the minutes that reflect that? You said you have been authorized to be the city administrator and I want to see any documentation that reflects that.?
Although Mayor Davenport has been acting in the place of the city administrator, Wood believes this is more to do with acting, and less to do with authority.
?I don?t believe you have the right to stop me from making this motion Royce,? said Wood. ?If there are no minutes to reflect that decision, then it?s not official or legal. We do not have a city administrator.?
The proper procedure for hiring a department head is the committee over that department makes a recommendation and the full board approves it. Not following this procedure would ?open a can of worms,? according to Davenport.
?I can cite several instances where it has been done that way,? said Wood. ?This board has just requested you to contact David Rutherford and you agreed and now I?m asking you to contact Hank Patton and do the same. What is the difference? Is it because you want to do one, and don?t want to do the other? I think we need a legal opinion. You are attempting to block something you don?t want to have happen.?
Rutherford was ruled out by the board as a city administrator candidate several months ago because of his salary demands, but has apparently fallen back in favor with several aldermen, who would now like to hire him.
Davenport denied the allegation by saying he is only keeping with proper procedure and upholding a current ordinance as the city?s acting city administrator.
?This is not personal,? said Davenport. ?I?m not trying to stop Patton from getting this position.?
Added Haley, ?I don?t see us going forward if we are going to continue to argue over policies. It has been the policy of this board to accept the recommendation of the committee. If we don?t follow procedure, then let?s just do away with the committees.?
With Wood?s motion stopped dead in its tracks, the discussion ended with no clear resolution and one upset alderman.
Immediately following this disagreement, an announcement was made by Davenport to appoint Wood to the Planning Commission. The position was one Wood had previously considered taking, but he refused Tuesday even when Davenport offered him the chair.
?No. I doubt that I will serve,? said Wood. ?I don?t think I would be interested at this point in time. I?m sure there would be some technicality in there that keeps me from becoming chairman.?
