Family of deceased patient sues NHC – Plantiffs claim facility is understaffed
Saying the care-giving agency ?placed profits above people,? the surviving family of a man who died after being in the care of the local NHC Healthcare facility is suing NHC and all its affiliates for wrongful death.
?NHC placed profits above people and they chronically failed to provide enough staff to meet their patients? needs,? said plaintiff attorney Lisa Circeo during opening arguments before Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley in a trial expected to last two to three weeks. ?The CNAs and employees there were victims too because they were set up to fail given the staffing.?
Christine Smartt and Ruby Kilgore, surviving relatives of the victim, Cheatum Myers, 89, are seeking compensatory and punitive damages against the national health care chain and its subordinate companies for conditions they say led to the suffering and death of the former nurseryman in the summer of 2005.
The 12-man, three-woman jury heard Circeo maintain last week that Myers was in critical condition when he was brought to River Park Hospital from NHC where he had stayed for over a year after being placed there following a fall that had broken his shoulder. Specifically, Circeo said Myers had an infection allegedly caused by a contaminated catheter, a fever of 103, a bed sore on his heel which went down to the bone, and pneumonia in both lungs.
?He wasn?t brought there from prison or from a war. He was brought there from NHC,? Circeo told jurors, noting Myers would later die from a heart attack allegedly brought on by his treatment at NHC. ?Even though he was known as a risk for falling, seeing he was brought there after a fall, he suffered seven falls while there.?
Circeo said one of the falls resulted in a hip fracture, a fracture which was not diagnosed for seven days.
?He laid there complaining of pain in his hip for a week before it was checked by a doctor,? Circeo said. ?Then staff was not told about the fracture and had him up walking on it.?
Circeo then recounted an incident where Myers was found soaked to the neck in his own urine and another time when he was found with his own feces smeared over his body, all caused by what Circeo maintained was greed for profits.
Specifically, Circeo said the complaints of under-staffing by employees there fell on deaf ears and that the NHC business was 1,000 patients over its budget, yet $80,000 under budget for employee salaries. She went on to say employees were later retaliated against for telling what they knew and that many pieces of evidence were shredded at the direction of the corporation.
However, the defense painted a dramatically different picture, saying that the NHC in McMinnville went above state regulations regarding the care of its patients.
??Care is our business? is our motto, and if you will notice, care comes before business,? said NHC defense attorney John Curtis. ?Regulations require at least two hours of direct care with patients but NHC went beyond that, providing three hours of direct care per day. The staffing was far above standards.?
Curtis pointed out the plaintiff had not told jurors the background of Mr. Myers when it came to his physical condition. First, Curtis noted Myers was a chronic smoker, thereby contributing to lung ailments which pre-existed and that he had a history of urinary problems.
He also noted the bed sore in question first manifested after he returned from the hospital following his hip surgery and that the sores found were treated while he was at NHC. As for the hip, Curtis said Myers was given treatment when he expressed having pain in the hip and that the doctor said he could be walked so long as he was assisted to keep most of his weight off the hip.
As for the number of falls, Curtis told jurors Myers was an independent man who wanted to do things for himself and that he would often get out of bed to go to the bathroom by himself, sometimes even removing alarms placed on him by the staff to warn of him getting out of bed.
?I think everyone agrees restraining Mr. Myers with restraints was not an option,? Curtis said, noting staff did what it could to encourage Myers to call an aide to help get out of bed.
The trial will feature a long list of witnesses, one which will include one of the NHC owners, Andy Adams, who Circeo said has about a $50 to $60 million stake in the company which was started in 1971 by his father.
The award for both compensatory and punitive damages will be determined by the jury at the end of the trial if they find any fault on the part of NHC or any of its subsidiaries.
