Housemate says he understands Winkler?s actions – Thomsen says he grew up with abusive father
Questions swirling around Mary Winkler?s recent behavior were apparently too much for the man who has been gracious enough to give her a place to live in Warren County.
Last week, Rudie Thomsen spoke out on the Miller in the Morning radio show on Nashville?s Supertalk 99.7 FM. In the interview, Thomsen stressed that Winkler was pushed to the limit by a history of domestic abuse ? a nightmare he said he experienced as a child.
?The primary thing is if you?re a member of the Church of Christ, if you get married you stay for the long haul,? said Thomsen. ?I?m a child from an abusive marriage and my mother was raised in the Church of Christ. And she was raised that no matter what, she stayed with my dad and she did.
?Believe me, there were times when I wish my mother would have blown my father away because there were times when he was violent and brutal and ugly,? Thomsen continued. ?Both my brother and my sister and myself have all been through counseling to deal with this and I think that?s why Mary stayed with him because she was a preacher?s wife.?
Winkler is accused of killing her husband, preacher Matthew Winkler, by shooting him with a .12-gauge shotgun while he slept. She has been living in Warren County since she was released on bond in August. Her next court date is scheduled for Feb. 22.
As conditions of Winkler?s bond, Judge McCraw Weber ruled she had to live in the home of Rudie and Kathy Thomsen. However, Winkler?s relatively low-key lifestyle grabbed attention recently when it was revealed she was enjoying herself at a local restaurant late at night.
That attention led radio host Kevin Miller to criticize Winkler, which in turn led to Thomsen?s decision to defend her on the show.
?I have been talking to her father and to her sisters and I have heard a lot of things you?re not aware of,? said Thomsen. ?While she was a youth minister?s wife at our church, I saw a couple things I didn?t think about at the time because we?re talking about a youth minister. We?re talking about a man of God and you don?t believe what happened would be on his shoulders, and some people at church saw some other things. Until you hear all the facts, we can?t start characterizing her as good-time Mary.?
Thomsen said he saw evidence Winkler was abused several years ago.
?One Sunday morning, Mary came in with a black eye and I asked her what happened,? said Thomsen. ?She said she was playing around with her two daughters and one of them elbowed her in the eye and I thought OK no problem because three or four years before that I had been in a pool with two of my nephews and been horsing around in there and one of them hit me in the eye with their elbow and blacked my eye. So I didn?t think anything about it until now. I didn?t think anything about it until what happened, happened.?
Thomsen said his wife suspected Winkler killed her husband the moment they heard about it.
?That morning when we heard Matthew had been shot, my wife leaned over and looked at me and said, ?I bet Mary did it,?? said Thomsen. ?I said ?What do you mean by that?? and she said ?I just think Mary did it? and of course we found out that was the truth.?
Thomsen painted a picture of what will very likely be Winkler?s defense. Since police reports indicate she has confessed to the murder, it doesn?t appear that point will be contested.
Instead, the defense looks content to portray Winkler as a woman trapped in an abusive and controlling relationship with seemingly no other way out.
?I can tell you this, Matthew was in charge of his household and Mary wouldn?t do anything unless Matthew told her to,? said Thomsen.
Thomsen admits he doesn?t know if that will be enough to beat first-degree murder charges.
?I don?t know if she?ll be exonerated,? said Thomsen. ?I doubt it because of what happened, but as long as she can be free, I want her to have that freedom.?
Thomsen said Winkler has been able to have regular contact with family members, but not her three children.
?Her father comes down to visit with her probably every weekend or every other weekend,? said Thomsen. ?The biggest thing is she hasn?t been able to see her children but one time since March.
?She has an arrangement with the people who are keeping her who are Matt Winkler?s parents. She has a schedule set up where she is supposed to call on Tuesday night and the girls can call Tuesday night and then they can write each other on certain weeks,? Thomsen continued. ?But here lately, like this week on Tuesday night she called and the girls weren?t there. That?s the biggest problem she?s having right now is not getting to see her daughters.?
