Photos of Winkler at bar generate controversy – Some residents say accused killer not harming anyone by socializing
Cellphone pictures showing accused killer Mary Winkler sitting at a restaurant bar on New Year?s Eve, smoking and drinking, have caused a stir in what had become a quiet pre-trial haven for the widow of slain preacher Matthew Winkler.
?What were we supposed to do, sit home and cry?? said Winkler?s friend and employer Matt Hash to WKRN Ch. 2. ?She?s not the preacher?s wife. She used to be, but he?s dead now. She?s not married. She?s nobody?s wife.?
Hash?s statement was in response to questions about the appropriateness of Winkler?s conduct. While adults certainly have the right to smoke and drink, Winkler?s behavior has raised eyebrows because she is accused of murdering her husband and because she?s received a tremendous amount of support from the Church of Christ.
The news reports, however, have been a lightning rod for controversy.
?This story was appalling and disgusting,? wrote Morrison resident Barbara Osredkar in a letter to the Standard. ?Mary has every right to conduct her life as she feels fit. Her life is in shambles at this point and I?m sure she is trying to keep it as normal and sane as possible.?
Added Liz Sanders in another letter, ?Mary was out with her fellow employees. What did it hurt? Who did it hurt??
The fact Winkler was at New York Grill does not constitute a violation of the terms of her bond. However, had she been in a slightly different setting, Winkler may have been facing a return to custody.
In her pre-trial supervision order, the paperwork specifically forbids her from going to a bar. However, it makes an allowance for going to alcohol-serving establishments which are mainly restaurants, such as New York Grill.
Her oath in being freed on bond reads, ?I will not use intoxicants of any kind to excess, or have in my possession narcotic drugs or marijuana,? Winkler swore. ?I will not enter any establishments whose prime purpose is to sell alcohol beverages.?
The oath goes on to require Winkler to submit to surprise drug screens and searches of her living quarters and vehicle. The order forbids her from leaving Warren County except to visit her children and attorneys.
East End Church of Christ preacher Garland Robinson says he doesn?t know all the details of Winkler?s case and can?t say whether reports of her drinking are true. Robinson says it can be a difficult judgment call when a church is trying to determine whether to assist someone financially.
?We want to be faithful to the Lord and be compassionate, but at the same time we don?t want to aid and abet someone?s bad habit,? said Robinson. ?If you give somebody a handout and you know they?re going to buy beer or cigarettes, I wouldn?t support it.?
Robinson added, ?Biblically speaking, it?s not all right to drink a beer.?
The controversy erupted after cellphone pictures were circulated of Winkler sitting at the bar at New York Grill. She was smoking with what appears to be containers of alcohol nearby. The pictures were captured by people at the bar who said they were stunned to see the accused killer ringing in the New Year.
Winkler is free on $750,000 bond awaiting her trial on murder charges for allegedly shooting her husband, Matthew Winkler, in the back with a shotgun as he slept in their home in Selmer, Tenn.
In her confession to the killing, Winkler said the couple had argued in the time leading up to the fatal shooting. Mrs. Winkler fled the crime scene with the couple?s three children. She and the children were found safe in the vacation resort town of Gulf Shores, Ala., 475 miles away.
Since she posted bond, Winkler has lived in Warren County with friends, while working at Cleaners Express.
