Skip to content

Legal move buys Myers more time – She remains free during Supreme Court appeal

Legal maneuvering will keep the mother of Myers Lane triple murderer Doug Myers out of jail indefinitely for her part in the crimes as she has filed an appeal with the Tennessee Supreme Court ? an appeal, that if accepted, could drag the case out several more years.

The defendant, Clementine Myers, 70, would have normally been arrested on a capias after her appeal was rejected by the Tennessee Court of Appeals. However, according to her attorney, Bob Peters, she will be allowed to stay out of jail on her present appeal bond while an appeal is brought before the state Supreme Court.

?I?m confident they will take the case,? Peters said of the high court which only hears a small percentage of the cases brought before it each year and rejects the rest.

Should the Supreme Court refuse to hear the case, Myers would be forced to serve her jail time. However, should the Supreme Court accept the case, it could take anywhere from six months to years for a ruling.

The Supreme Court should determine whether it hears the case in a few months.

The elderly Myers has been free on appeal bond for three years since her conviction in early 2004 for paying hush money to murder conspiracy member Johnny Lewis, who is serving 65 years for his part in the triple murders, alongside Doug Myers who is serving life.

The court originally ruled the state could not re-try Ms. Myers on murder conspiracy charges after the jury hung on that count. However, the appeals court, in its recent decision, found it would not be double jeopardy. The appellate court also upheld her 20-month sentence on the lesser count of criminally negligent homicide for which she was convicted during the 2004 trial.

A focus of the Supreme Court appeal is whether a re-trial of Myers on the murder conspiracy charge, a crime which carries 15 to 25 years, would constitute double jeopardy. The appellate court has already ruled it did not feel Myers? rights would be violated should prosecutors decide to try her again, something District Attorney General Lisa Zavogiannis said is not automatic until she reviews the evidence to determine if it is a sound case.

Clementine?s son, Doug Myers, was convicted for the actual murders as prosecutors proved he beat his longtime girlfriend, Dianne Watts, to death with a bat before beating Jessica Watts and Chelsie Smith nearly to death and then having Lewis set the house on fire.

The apparent ending of the appeals had many of the victims? family members excited with some admitting they thought, given her advanced age, that Clementine Myers may die before seeing a day in jail.

Leave a Comment