Hispanic teen claims he?s not 18 – At 17, he faces much shorter time in custody
A Hispanic teen accused of having sex with a 12-year-old girl who skipped school for their tryst may have dodged a quarter century behind bars after his defense produced documents showing he is a juvenile.
?I am 17,? said Eduardo Orellano through a translator when asked his true age by General Sessions Judge Larry Ross.
His claim came after his defense showed documentation obtained from the Mexican Consulate that the boy is in fact 17, prompting the court Tuesday to remove the youth from Warren County Jail, place him in juvenile detention in Cookeville and transfer his case to Juvenile Court.
The one-year age difference has tremendous significance. Orellano would have faced 15 to 25 years on child rape charges, but faces only confinement in a juvenile facility until his 19th birthday if convicted as a juvenile.
Both he and the 12-year-old girl, who has been sanctioned by the court and school for her part in sneaking off Warren County Middle School campus to meet Orellano, have admitted to having sex while she was playing hooky last month. The boy maintains he did not realize how young the girl is.
The girl was caught when she tried to slip back onto school grounds to meet her grandmother for her ride home.
She then admitted the incident and Orellano was picked up for the crime.
Although the sex was consensual, according to both parties, the law treats any adult having sex with a person under 12 as a child rapist. Orellano faces the same charge as a juvenile, however his potential punishment is much less.
While clear for the time being, Orellano is not out of the woods completely as prosecutors are still verifying the documents.
?We?re always suspicious of documents like this that just seem to pop up,? said assistant district attorney Tom Miner, noting their office will continue working with INS to determine the validity of the proof of age.
In addition to the paperwork showing Orellano is 17, prosecutors could opt to try to transfer him back to adult court through a transfer hearing where underage persons can be made to stand trial as adults in serious cases.
