City may take county to court – Dispute revolves around school system funding
McMinnville officials are considering a legal move that could begin a drawn-out courtroom battle between city and county over 1 cent in local option sales tax.
In 1968, McMinnville and Warren County consolidated their individual school systems and the city agreed to deed everything ‘ buildings and debt ‘ over to the county. Because the debt was in the single-digit millions at the time, the city agreed to allocate 1 cent of the sales tax to be used solely and exclusively for school purposes.
Although only 1 cent, it amounted to $1.7 million last year. Because the contract has no ending date, the county has been collecting 1 cent of the city’s sales tax for almost 40 years with the city only collecting one-eighth of 1 cent.
City officials have considered taking back the penny in the past but haven’t gone any further than discussing the idea. When budget talks began this year, McMinnville officials once again began considering the move.
In the last few weeks, officials requested that city administrator David Rutherford look into the agreement. During a recent Finance Committee meeting, officials requested Rutherford also look into what the city would have to do legally to take back the penny for the benefit of city residents.
At this time, state changes are encouraging the move.
‘It is worth looking into because of the fact that the state is coming up with a new funding program now,’ said Rutherford. ‘If we don’t do something to cause a positive impact of state dollars, we will have to continue to pay for something locally that maybe the state would pay for.’
Apparently other counties are considering the same discussions between their city and county governments. According to Rutherford, he saw recently in the news where the Loudon County Commission refused to fund just under $2 million in its school budget to see what the state would give. That measure passed by a 6-4 vote.
The current local budget for the Warren County School System is slightly more than $11.5 million annually. Due to a maintenance of effort law, that amount can only be reduced if enrollment drops.
If the city takes $1.7 million and the state doesn’t step in with the funding, county residents would have to make up that deficit.
According to Alderman Billy Wood, the news won’t be good for residents who live outside McMinnville city limits. If $1.7 million is needed by the county, taxes would most likely be raised.
For city residents, even though they are county residents too, the news is better. While county taxes would likely rise, city property taxes would plummet.
In the event taking back the tax is possible, a slow withdrawal of the 1 cent sales tax would lessen the impact for the county. If that is the case, a 50 percent decrease the first year, a 25 percent decrease the second year, and 25 percent decrease the third year will be suggested.
Officials have asked Rutherford to look into the legal costs of a courtroom battle and which counsel would be used, as the city’s current legal counsel has a conflict of interest.
According to County Executive John Pelham, his office has had no official contact at this time regarding the city’s 1 cent sales tax contribution and until an official contact has been made, no official comment will be made.
Even if the penny is retrieved, city residents will still be contributing to the school system by county property taxes and wheel tax revenues, the same as county residents.
