Upon Further Review: Titans? QB future no sure thing
As the NFL draft quickly approaches, general mangers and coaches are busy shuffling through draft reports and looking at player stats from last week?s NFL scouting combine.
If Houston takes Reggie Bush and Matt Leinart goes to the Saints, then Young will go to the Titans, right? Maybe not.
Over the past couple of months Vince Young has been rumored to be Tennessee?s top choice. The Titans have the third pick in this year?s draft and should be looking for a franchise quarterback, someone to replace Steve McNair if not this year, then sometime in the near future.
With Young and McNair being friends, it seemed the Texas quarterback was headed to Nashville. But don?t pencil him in just yet.
Things are starting to get very interesting, especially now that Jay Cutler has emerged as one of the top-rated quarterbacks after the combine workout.
The hometown boy has seen his stock climb after last week?s workout, and with the draft coming up at the end of April, it?s sure to rise a little more.
It seems that Titans offensive coordinator Norm Chow may be having second thoughts about Young?s ability to run the Tennessee offensive system.
And then there?s the little matter of a low score on the Wonderlic test. Yes, that?s what I said, the Wonderlic test. Young apparently had a low score of six on his first test, and I believe they allowed him to take a second test where he scored a 16. But that?s still pretty low.
If you wonder what I?m talking about, the Wonderlic is a test the NFL has been using for 30 years. It?s a test that provides indicators of an individual?s ability to cope with the complexities of any particular occupation.
The test has 50 questions that the participant is allowed 12 minutes to answer. The average test score is 21, and is equivalent to an average IQ of 100.
The average score for quarterbacks and offensive lineman is 25, with all other positions averaging 20. Fifty is the highest possible score, and shows superior intelligence, while 21 is average intelligence, 14 is equivalent to unskilled workers and below 14 is moron level.
Now here is a list of several scores by NFL players over the past several years, but some of these scores are unconfirmed.
Pat McInally: 50, Brian Griese: 39, Eli Manning: 39, Tom Brady: 33, Peyton Manning: 28, Randall Cunningham: 15 and Jeff George had a 10.
Now, Mr. Nunley and myself couldn?t help but take the test for ourselves, with both of us scoring a 44. Not bad for a couple of sports guys. OK, we took the short version of the test, but it still puts us up there in the genius category.
But back to the subject, could the Titans pass on Young and pick Cutler? It?s very possible, stranger things have happened. Just because you get a top five or even a top 10 pick doesn?t mean he?s going to be a super star in the NFL.
I believe the biggest concern about Young is his game has been as much about running as it has throwing. Coaches in the NFL seem to be worried about his eagerness to run out of the formation.
This is just a guess, but the first time he gets nailed running out of the shotgun by Ray Lewis or Zach Thomas, I?ll say he?ll be content to stand back there and throw the ball.
