Skip to content

Consumer Reports – Alternatives to back surgery

When back pain is disabling and prolonged, surgery may be offered as a treatment. While that makes sense in a few cases, according to Consumer Reports, recent evidence suggests that many people can get just as good ‘ or even better ‘ results with noninvasive treatments that they can do largely or entirely on their own.

According to CR’s medical consultants, consider surgery in the following circumstances:

‘ When there’s a serious spinal disorder, such as a tumor, infection or fracture.

‘ When the pain is accompanied by a neurological problem in the legs that’s clearly related to a low-back abnormality on an MRI or CT scan.

‘ When disabling pain in the back, buttocks or legs is clearly linked with an abnormal scan and persists for six weeks or more despite conservative treatment.

But when a doctor recommends surgery and there’s no emergency, it may pay to get a second opinion from another surgeon or a physiatrist (a physician who specializes in rehabilitation).

MIND-BODY METHODS

A two-year study in a November 2006 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association found that people with a herniated disk and low-back pain got just as much pain relief from nonsurgical rehabilitation as from surgical removal of the damaged part of the disk. With both treatments, most of the relief occurred within the first three months.

In another study, published in a May 2005 issue of the British Medical Journal, spinal-fusion surgery (often used to stabilize the spine after disk removal) was compared with noninvasive treatment. This involved intensive exercise plus cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT). CBT helps people replace negative thoughts with positive ones, and also treats accompanying depression, which tends to increase sensitivity to pain. The noninvasive treatments were as effective as the surgery in easing pain, improving mobility and helping people resume work.

In addition, an analysis of the pooled results of numerous studies, published in the January 2007 issue of Health Psychology, indicated that cognitive-behavioral therapy or mind-body methods ‘ with or without exercise ‘ significantly reduced long-standing back pain compared with routine treatment using other techniques such as acupuncture, message and various injections. Effective mind-body methods include hypnosis (and subsequent self-hypnosis), biofeedback and relaxation methods.

START WITH A PLAN

For noninvasive treatment of stubborn back pain, it makes sense to get an individualized treatment program by consulting a physiatrist, physical therapist or team of experts at a multidisciplinary pain center. The plan should include a gradually increasing exercise regimen that includes stretching, strengthening and low-impact aerobic exercise such as walking or swimming. Proper exercise is essential for treating back pain: It can build back muscle, boost flexibility, increase endorphins and ease depression.

Acupuncture, message, Pilates, spinal manipulation and yoga may also help relieve back pain and speed recovery. When seeking such alternative treatments, heed your personal preferences. Psychological or relaxation methods should be part of the plan, especially if you’re depressed or can’t overcome the fear that exercise will cause further pain or injury.

CONFIDENCE BREEDS BENEFITS

Research suggests that the strongest predictor of how you’ll respond to any back treatment may simply be whether you have confidence in the remedy. In one study that compared acupuncture with massage, for example, back-pain sufferers who expressed enthusiasm for their assigned therapy before starting were five times as likely to experience substantial benefits as the initially skeptical volunteers.

Leave a Comment